China brain is a hypothetical scenario that asks whether a nation of people simulating neurons could have a mind or consciousness. It is related to the Chinese room scenario and the problem of multiple realizability in functionalism.
Chinese room
John Searle's Chinese room argument challenges the idea that a computer can have a mind or understand language, by analogy with a person who follows instructions but does not speak Chinese. The article reviews the history, philosophy and criticism of this influential thought experiment in artificial intelligence and cognitive science.
The Chinese Room Argument
The argument and thought-experiment now generally known as the Chinese Room Argument was first published in a 1980 article by American philosopher John Searle (1932- ). ... seen, even if this is true it begs the question of just whose consciousness a brain creates. Roger Sperry's split-brain experiments suggest that perhaps there can be two ...
PDF The China Brain
The China Brain: Suppose we convert the government of China to functionalism, and we convince its officials to realize a human mind for an hour. We provide each of the billion people in China (I chose China because it has a billion inhabitants) with a specially designed two-way radio that connects them in the appropriate way to other persons and to
China Brain Argument
The China Brain Argument is a thought experiment that explores the nature of consciousness and its relationship to functionalism by imagining a scenario where the entire function of a human brain is replicated in a computer system distributed across China. This argument raises questions about whether such a system could possess consciousness or subjective experience, despite being functionally ...
How can we possibly know if the entire populous of the human race is
The China brain: In the philosophy of mind, the China brain thought experiment (also known as the Chinese Nation or Chinese Gym) considers what would happen if the entire population of China were asked to simulate the action of one neuron in the brain, using telephones or walkie-talkies to simulate the axons and dendrites that connect neurons.. Now my question, states that what if unknowingly ...
(PDF) The Illusion of Group Minds
Ned Block's (1978) "China Brain" thought experiment is perhaps the most famous conceptualization of the possibility of a group mind, the attribution of phenomenal consciousness to a group of individuals taken as a whole. While Block himself argued against group minds, others have bitten the bullet and supported the existence of collective ...
A CLOSER LOOK AT THE CHINESE NATION ARGUMENT
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block (1978) to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness. I argue that it does not. Block's case rests on a single premise, P, in the following argument: (P) a creature with a China Brain would lack qualitative ...
(PDF) A2 Philosophy
Ned Block provides a very clear explanation of the thought experiment: imagine that we have a complete functional description of Person A's mental states - the population of China (approximately the same as the number of neurons in the brain) is connected to a human body and, using radio transmitters performs the equivalent functional role ...
Philosophy of mind
Philosophy of mind - Chinese Blocks, Nation, China: There are more than one billion people in China, and there are roughly one billion neurons in the brain. Suppose that the functional relations that functionalists claim are constitutive of human mental life are ultimately definable in terms of firing patterns among assemblages of neurons. Now imagine that, perhaps as a celebration, it is ...
An anti-anti-functionalist account of consciousness
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness. I argue that it does not. Block's case rests on a single premise, P, in the following argument: a creature with a China Brain would lack qualitative experience, despite ...
Physicalism
Physicalism is the view that everything is physical or supervenes on the physical. Learn about four types of physicalist theories of the mind: behaviourism, type identity, functionalism, and eliminativism.
An Anti-Anti-Functionalist Account of Consciousness
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block (1978) to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness.
emergence
The famous thought experiment is the China brain thought experiment. There are many responses to this, arguing both sides. It also depends on which school of thought you believe in - behavioralism, functionalism, eliminative materialism, dualism, etc. We need to know more about consciousness, artificial intelligence, and neurology to be able ...
[Phil. of mind] Why doesn't the 'China brain' reproduce mental ...
1: It is possible for the population of China to replicate the functions of the brain through the use of Walkee talkee (or similar), with each person stimulating the next in the manner of neurons. 2: We would not say that this China Brain is able to have mental states. 3: Therefore mental states cannot be explained fully by functional states.
About: China brain
In the philosophy of mind, the China brain thought experiment (also known as the Chinese Nation or Chinese Gym) considers what would happen if each member of the Chinese nation were asked to simulate the action of one neuron in the brain, using telephones or walkie-talkies to simulate the axons and dendrites that connect neurons.
An anti-anti-functionalist account of consciousness
The China Brain thought experiment rests entirely upon our having certain intuitions 4. So the China Brain thought experiment is irrelevant —perhaps that is worse than being false! In any case the China Brain fails to provide a true counterexample to functionalism. If you still aren't convinced, I do have one last nail for its coffin, but ...
China brain thought experiment
A fiction to challenge the functionalist conception of the mind, which identifies mental states with functions or roles. It asks whether a system of human agents communicating by radio links could have a mind or consciousness.
COMMENTS
China brain is a hypothetical scenario that asks whether a nation of people simulating neurons could have a mind or consciousness. It is related to the Chinese room scenario and the problem of multiple realizability in functionalism.
John Searle's Chinese room argument challenges the idea that a computer can have a mind or understand language, by analogy with a person who follows instructions but does not speak Chinese. The article reviews the history, philosophy and criticism of this influential thought experiment in artificial intelligence and cognitive science.
The argument and thought-experiment now generally known as the Chinese Room Argument was first published in a 1980 article by American philosopher John Searle (1932- ). ... seen, even if this is true it begs the question of just whose consciousness a brain creates. Roger Sperry's split-brain experiments suggest that perhaps there can be two ...
The China Brain: Suppose we convert the government of China to functionalism, and we convince its officials to realize a human mind for an hour. We provide each of the billion people in China (I chose China because it has a billion inhabitants) with a specially designed two-way radio that connects them in the appropriate way to other persons and to
The China Brain Argument is a thought experiment that explores the nature of consciousness and its relationship to functionalism by imagining a scenario where the entire function of a human brain is replicated in a computer system distributed across China. This argument raises questions about whether such a system could possess consciousness or subjective experience, despite being functionally ...
The China brain: In the philosophy of mind, the China brain thought experiment (also known as the Chinese Nation or Chinese Gym) considers what would happen if the entire population of China were asked to simulate the action of one neuron in the brain, using telephones or walkie-talkies to simulate the axons and dendrites that connect neurons.. Now my question, states that what if unknowingly ...
Ned Block's (1978) "China Brain" thought experiment is perhaps the most famous conceptualization of the possibility of a group mind, the attribution of phenomenal consciousness to a group of individuals taken as a whole. While Block himself argued against group minds, others have bitten the bullet and supported the existence of collective ...
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block (1978) to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness. I argue that it does not. Block's case rests on a single premise, P, in the following argument: (P) a creature with a China Brain would lack qualitative ...
Ned Block provides a very clear explanation of the thought experiment: imagine that we have a complete functional description of Person A's mental states - the population of China (approximately the same as the number of neurons in the brain) is connected to a human body and, using radio transmitters performs the equivalent functional role ...
Philosophy of mind - Chinese Blocks, Nation, China: There are more than one billion people in China, and there are roughly one billion neurons in the brain. Suppose that the functional relations that functionalists claim are constitutive of human mental life are ultimately definable in terms of firing patterns among assemblages of neurons. Now imagine that, perhaps as a celebration, it is ...
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness. I argue that it does not. Block's case rests on a single premise, P, in the following argument: a creature with a China Brain would lack qualitative experience, despite ...
Physicalism is the view that everything is physical or supervenes on the physical. Learn about four types of physicalist theories of the mind: behaviourism, type identity, functionalism, and eliminativism.
In this paper I scrutinize the so-called China Brain thought experiment famously articulated by Ned Block (1978) to see whether it refutes functionalism as a theory of consciousness.
The famous thought experiment is the China brain thought experiment. There are many responses to this, arguing both sides. It also depends on which school of thought you believe in - behavioralism, functionalism, eliminative materialism, dualism, etc. We need to know more about consciousness, artificial intelligence, and neurology to be able ...
1: It is possible for the population of China to replicate the functions of the brain through the use of Walkee talkee (or similar), with each person stimulating the next in the manner of neurons. 2: We would not say that this China Brain is able to have mental states. 3: Therefore mental states cannot be explained fully by functional states.
In the philosophy of mind, the China brain thought experiment (also known as the Chinese Nation or Chinese Gym) considers what would happen if each member of the Chinese nation were asked to simulate the action of one neuron in the brain, using telephones or walkie-talkies to simulate the axons and dendrites that connect neurons.
The China Brain thought experiment rests entirely upon our having certain intuitions 4. So the China Brain thought experiment is irrelevant —perhaps that is worse than being false! In any case the China Brain fails to provide a true counterexample to functionalism. If you still aren't convinced, I do have one last nail for its coffin, but ...
A fiction to challenge the functionalist conception of the mind, which identifies mental states with functions or roles. It asks whether a system of human agents communicating by radio links could have a mind or consciousness.