is case study action research

Action Research vs. Case Study

What's the difference.

Action research and case study are both research methodologies used in social sciences to investigate and understand complex phenomena. However, they differ in their approach and purpose. Action research is a collaborative and participatory approach that involves researchers and practitioners working together to identify and solve practical problems in real-world settings. It aims to bring about positive change and improvement in the context being studied. On the other hand, case study is an in-depth and detailed examination of a particular individual, group, or situation. It focuses on understanding the unique characteristics and dynamics of the case being studied and often involves extensive data collection and analysis. While action research emphasizes practical application and problem-solving, case study emphasizes detailed exploration and understanding of a specific case.

Further Detail

Introduction.

Action research and case study are two widely used research methodologies in various fields. While both approaches aim to gain insights and understanding, they differ in their focus, design, and implementation. This article will explore the attributes of action research and case study, highlighting their similarities and differences.

Action Research

Action research is a participatory approach that involves collaboration between researchers and practitioners to address real-world problems. It emphasizes the active involvement of stakeholders in the research process, aiming to bring about practical change and improvement. Action research typically follows a cyclical process, consisting of planning, action, observation, and reflection.

One of the key attributes of action research is its focus on generating knowledge that is directly applicable to the context in which it is conducted. It aims to bridge the gap between theory and practice by actively involving practitioners in the research process. This participatory nature allows for a deeper understanding of the complexities and nuances of the problem being investigated.

Action research often involves multiple iterations, with each cycle building upon the insights gained from the previous one. This iterative approach allows for continuous learning and adaptation, enabling researchers to refine their interventions and strategies based on the feedback received. It also promotes a sense of ownership and empowerment among the participants, as they actively contribute to the research process.

Furthermore, action research is characterized by its emphasis on collaboration and co-learning. It encourages the exchange of ideas and knowledge between researchers and practitioners, fostering a sense of shared responsibility and collective action. This collaborative approach not only enhances the quality of the research but also increases the likelihood of successful implementation of the findings.

In summary, action research is a participatory and iterative approach that aims to generate practical knowledge through collaboration between researchers and practitioners. It focuses on addressing real-world problems and promoting positive change within specific contexts.

Case study, on the other hand, is an in-depth investigation of a particular phenomenon, event, or individual. It involves the detailed examination of a specific case or cases to gain a comprehensive understanding of the subject under study. Case studies can be conducted using various research methods, such as interviews, observations, and document analysis.

One of the key attributes of case study research is its ability to provide rich and detailed insights into complex phenomena. By focusing on a specific case, researchers can delve deep into the intricacies and unique aspects of the subject, uncovering valuable information that may not be easily captured through other research methods.

Case studies are often used to explore and understand real-life situations in their natural settings. They allow researchers to examine the context and dynamics surrounding the case, providing a holistic view of the phenomenon under investigation. This contextual understanding is crucial for gaining a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the subject.

Furthermore, case studies are particularly useful when the boundaries between the phenomenon and its context are not clearly defined. They allow for the exploration of complex and multifaceted issues, enabling researchers to capture the interplay of various factors and variables. This holistic approach enhances the validity and reliability of the findings.

Moreover, case studies can be exploratory, descriptive, or explanatory in nature, depending on the research questions and objectives. They can be used to generate hypotheses, provide detailed descriptions, or test theoretical frameworks. This versatility makes case study research applicable in various fields, including psychology, sociology, business, and education.

In summary, case study research is an in-depth investigation of a specific phenomenon, providing rich and detailed insights into complex situations. It focuses on understanding the context and dynamics surrounding the case, allowing for a comprehensive exploration of multifaceted issues.

Similarities

While action research and case study differ in their focus and design, they also share some common attributes. Both approaches aim to gain insights and understanding, albeit through different means. They both involve the collection and analysis of data to inform decision-making and improve practice.

Furthermore, both action research and case study can be conducted in naturalistic settings, allowing for the examination of real-life situations. They both emphasize the importance of context and seek to understand the complexities and nuances of the phenomena under investigation.

Moreover, both methodologies can involve multiple data collection methods, such as interviews, observations, and document analysis. They both require careful planning and design to ensure the validity and reliability of the findings.

Additionally, both action research and case study can contribute to theory development. While action research focuses on generating practical knowledge, it can also inform and contribute to theoretical frameworks. Similarly, case studies can provide empirical evidence that can be used to refine and expand existing theories.

In summary, action research and case study share common attributes, including their aim to gain insights and understanding, their focus on real-life situations, their emphasis on context, their use of multiple data collection methods, and their potential contribution to theory development.

Action research and case study are two distinct research methodologies that offer unique approaches to gaining insights and understanding. Action research emphasizes collaboration, participation, and practical change, while case study focuses on in-depth investigation and contextual understanding. Despite their differences, both approaches contribute to knowledge generation and have the potential to inform theory and practice. Researchers should carefully consider the nature of their research questions and objectives to determine which approach is most suitable for their study.

Comparisons may contain inaccurate information about people, places, or facts. Please report any issues.

Home » Education » Difference Between Action Research and Case Study

Difference Between Action Research and Case Study

Main difference – action research vs case study.

Research is the careful study of a given field or problem in order to discover new facts or principles. Action research and case study are two types of research, which are mainly used in the field of social sciences and humanities. The main difference between action research and case study is their purpose; an action research study aims to solve an immediate problem whereas a case study aims to provide an in-depth analysis of a situation or case over a long period of time.

1. What is Action Research?      – Definition, Features, Purpose, Process

2. What is Case Study?      – Definition, Features, Purpose, Process

What is Action Research

Action research is a type of a research study that is initiated to solve an immediate problem. It may involve a variety of analytical, investigative and evaluative research methods designed to diagnose and solve problems. It has been defined as “a disciplined process of inquiry conducted by and for those taking the action. The primary reason for engaging in action research is to assist the “actor” in improving and/or refining his or her actions” (Sagor, 2000). This type of research is typically used in the field of education. Action research studies are generally conductors by educators, who also act as participants.

Here, an individual researcher or a group of researchers identify a problem, examine its causes and try to arrive at a solution to the problem. The action research process is as follows.

Action Research Process

• Identify a problem to research
• Clarify theories
• Identify research questions
• Collect data on the problem
• Organise, analyse, and interpret the data
• Create a plan to address the problem
• Implement the above-mentioned plan
• Evaluate the results of the actions taken

The above process will keep repeating. Action research is also known as cycle of inquiry or cycle of action since it follows a specific process that is repeated over time.

What is a Case Study

A case study is basically an in-depth examination of a particular event, situation or an individual. It is a type of research that is designed to explore and understand complex issues; however, it involves detailed contextual analysis of only a limited number of events or situations. It has been defined as “an empirical inquiry that investigates a contemporary phenomenon within its real-life context; when the boundaries between phenomenon and context are not clearly evident; and in which multiple sources of evidence are used.” (Yin, 1984)

Case studies are used in a variety of fields, but fields like sociology and education seem to use them the most. They can be used to probe into community-based problems such as illiteracy, unemployment, poverty, and drug addiction. 

Case studies involve both quantitative and qualitative data and allow the researchers to see beyond statistical results and understand human conditions. Furthermore, case studies can be classified into three categories, known as exploratory, descriptive and explanatory case studies.

However, case studies are also criticised since the study of a limited number of events or cases cannot easily establish generality or reliability of the findings. The process of a case study is generally as follows:

Case Study Process

• Identifying and defining the research questions
• Selecting the cases and deciding techniques for data collection and analysis
• Collecting data in the field
• Evaluating and analysing the data
• Preparing the report

Action Research : Action research is a type of a research study that is initiated to solve an immediate problem.

Case Study : Case study is an in-depth analysis of a particular event or case over a long period of time.                         

Action Research : Action research involves solving a problem.

Case Study : Case studies involve observing and analysing a situation.

Action Research : Action research studies are mainly used in the field of education.

Case Study : Case studies are used in many fields; they can be specially used with community problems such as unemployment, poverty, etc.

Action Research : Action research always involve providing a solution to a problem.

Case Study : Case studies do not provide a solution to a problem.

Participants

Action Research : Researchers can also act as participants of the research.

Case Study : Researchers generally don’t take part in the research study.

Zainal, Zaidah.  Case study as a research method . N.p.: n.p., 7 June 2007. PDF.

 Soy, Susan K. (1997).  The case study as a research method . Unpublished paper, University of Texas at Austin.

Sagor, Richard.  Guiding school improvement with action research . Ascd, 2000.

Image Courtesy: Pixabay

About the Author: Hasa

Hasanthi is a seasoned content writer and editor with over 8 years of experience. Armed with a BA degree in English and a knack for digital marketing, she explores her passions for literature, history, culture, and food through her engaging and informative writing.

​You May Also Like These

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Action Research vs. Case Study — What's the Difference?

Difference Between Action Research and Case Study

Table of contents, key differences, comparison chart, role of researcher, data collection, generalizability, compare with definitions, action research, common curiosities, is action research qualitative or quantitative, what's the primary purpose of action research, what is action research, how does action research differ from traditional research, when is a case study used, who typically conducts action research, how is data gathered in action research, how is data collected in a case study, is action research collaborative, is a case study qualitative or quantitative, how long does a case study last, does action research require a hypothesis, what are some criticisms of action research, can action research be published, are case study findings generalizable, can a case study cover multiple cases, how are case study findings presented, what's the main criticism of case studies, is a case study used only in social sciences, what is a case study, share your discovery.

Author Spotlight

Popular Comparisons

Trending Comparisons

New Comparisons

Trending Terms

Action Research vs. Case Study: What's the Difference?

Key Differences

Comparison chart, primary aim, participant role, methodology, action research and case study definitions, action research, who conducts "action research", does a "case study" focus on one entity, is "action research" participatory, are subjects in "action research" considered co-researchers, can "action research" effect immediate change, is a "case study" used for theoretical insights, is "action research" iterative, can a "case study" be used in qualitative research, is "action research" subjective, can "case studies" be subjective, where is "action research" common, what's the scope of a "case study", how is data collected in "action research", are multiple sources used in a "case study", how long does a "case study" take, what's a key benefit of "action research", do "action research" results apply beyond the initial situation, does a "case study" require participant involvement, what fields use "case studies", why choose a "case study" approach.

Trending Comparisons

Popular Comparisons

New Comparisons

• Software Engineering Tutorial
• Software Development Life Cycle
• Waterfall Model
• Software Requirements
• Software Measurement and Metrics
• Software Design Process
• System configuration management
• Software Maintenance
• Software Development Tutorial
• Software Testing Tutorial
• Product Management Tutorial
• Project Management Tutorial
• Agile Methodology
• Selenium Basics

Difference between Case Study and Action research

1. Action Research : Action Research is a type of qualitative research. As the name suggests it is more action oriented in order to solve an immediate problem. Action research helps the researcher to improvise its current practices and is applied for researching into issues. It aims to learn through action leading to personal or professional development means focuses on improving and/or refining actions. This type research generally used in field of education to bridge the gap between educational theory and professional practice by improvising their current practices. This helps in observing the problem and identifying the cause and then addressing the issue so mainly it is more focused on immediate addressing to practical problems and in generating knowledge to produce change.

2. Case Study : Case study research refers to an in-depth examination of a particular event or individual or a group of individuals. It is more of a qualitative method of research where it understand complex issues by deeply observing and analyzing the event or situation by collecting and reporting the data related to the event or situation. Case study research is more towards description rather than immediate cause and effect finding. Case study is categorized into three ways i.e., exploratory, explanatory and descriptive based on research method. These studies involve both quantitative and qualitative data. This type of research can be used to address community-based problems like illiteracy, unemployment, poverty, and drug addiction.

Difference between Case study and Action Research :

Similar Reads

• Difference between Case Study and Action research 1. Action Research : Action Research is a type of qualitative research. As the name suggests it is more action oriented in order to solve an immediate problem. Action research helps the researcher to improvise its current practices and is applied for researching into issues. It aims to learn through 3 min read
• Difference between Test Case and Test Script In the field of software testing, two terms often emerge: Test Case and Test Script are two synonyms used interchangeably in test throughout the project. Both are essential in proving the integrity of a software application while testing does involve the same function as verification but they differ 6 min read
• Difference between Use Case and Test Case Software testing is a process of examining whether the actual product matches the expected requirements and ensures that the software product is bug-free. The purpose of software testing is to identify bugs, errors, or missing requirements in contrast to the actual requirements. In the software test 4 min read
• Difference Between PERT and CPM Project Evaluation and Review Technique (PERT) and Critical Path Method (CPM) are very important analytical techniques of Project Management for planning and controlling a project. PERT and CRM are helpful tools for managing tasks that every project manager should implement. Understanding the differ 5 min read
• Difference between ERP and IWMS 1. Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) : Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP), as name suggests, is a software tool that helps one to manage resources within organization and makes it more effective. 2. Integrated Workplace Management System (IWMS) : Integrated Workplace Management System (IWMS), as na 2 min read
• Difference between Agile and Scrum Testing Agile Testing: Agile testing is a type of software testing that is performed alongside the software development. It is the part of Agile Software Development in which the development and the testing process goes side by side. When in software development life cycle development and the testing goes p 2 min read
• Difference between SFA and CRM 1. Sales-Force Automation (SFA) : Sales-Force Automation technique helps to keep a track of sales person performance, as they plays major role in driving sales and contact information of probable customers and hence affecting revenues of business. This was reason that SFA came into existence for que 2 min read
• Difference between Agile and SDLC In software development, Agile and SDLC (Software Development Life Cycle) are two distinct methodologies. Agile emphasizes iterative development, rapid feedback, and flexibility to adapt to changing requirements, ideal for small-scale projects. SDLC, follows a systematic approach with sequential sta 4 min read
• Difference between BRD and SRS The role of formulating a document is to understand fundamentals that will be compelled to develop robust software. Type of record expectation depends upon business type, their criteria, how company processes, and what kind of software is to be developed. Let us understand common documents which are 3 min read
• Difference between Data Science and Operations Research 1. Data Science : It’s a set of methodologies of taking thousands of forms of data that are available to us today and using them to draw meaningful conclusions. Data is being collected all around us, every like, click, email, credit card swipe, or tweet is a new piece of data that can better describ 3 min read
• Difference between Product and Process Product: In the context of software engineering, Product includes any software manufactured based on the customer's request. This can be a problem solving software or computer based system. It can also be said that this is the result of a project. Process: Process is a set of sequence steps that hav 2 min read
• Difference between Survey and Experiment 1. Survey : Survey refers to the way of gathering information regarding a variable under study from all or a specified number of respondents of the universe. Surveys are carried out by maintaining a structured form of data collection, through interview, questionnaire, case study etc. In surveys prep 3 min read
• Difference Between Adaptation and Mitigation Difference Between Adaptation and Mitigation: Adaptation and mitigation are two methods that can be used to fix various problems in the world like climate change, pollution, water treatment, and many more. These both occur in many things like humans developing new climate change strategies, animals 3 min read
• Difference between IWMS and CAFM 1. Integrated Work Management System (IWMS) : Integrated Work Management System (IWMS), as name suggests, is a software tool that is used to manage every aspect related to workplace i.e. all work within organization. 2. Computer-Aided Facility Management (CAFM) : Computer-Aided Facility Management ( 2 min read
• Difference between RPA and BPM 1. Robotics Process Automation (RPA) : Robotics Process Automation (RPA) is a software technology which automates the repetitive tasks that were previously processed by human/employee. It configures bots or uses software robots to complete monotonous and time consuming task. So that employees gets t 3 min read
• Difference between Jira and Asana Jira and Asana are both popular project management tools but serve different primary purposes. Jira is Originally designed for software development teams, Jira focuses on issue and bug tracking, agile project management, and software development processes like Scrum and Kanban. Asana is Geared towar 4 min read
• Difference between ERP and ERP II 1. Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP): Enterprise Resource Planning is the foundation system for domestic and global operations, supporting most or all functional areas in their daily operations. is one of the more common categories of business software, especially with large-scale businesses. It is 2 min read
• Difference between Software and Tool 1. Software : Software, as name suggest, is simply a collection of data or set of instructions that are especially designed to perform well defined functions as well as direct operation of computer and instruct on how to use them. 2. Tool : Tool, as name suggests, are software development tools that 2 min read
• Difference between Software and Data 1. Software : Software, as name suggest, is simply a type of software systems or application in any program or group of programs that is especially designed for customer or end user and runs on computer system. 2. Data : Data, as name suggests, is simply a representation of facts, concepts, informat 2 min read
• Difference Between
• Software Engineering

Improve your Coding Skills with Practice

What kind of Experience do you want to share?

• Trending Categories

• Selected Reading
• UPSC IAS Exams Notes
• Developer's Best Practices
• Questions and Answers
• Effective Resume Writing
• HR Interview Questions
• Computer Glossary

Difference between Case Study and Action Research

A case study is a topic in which a study is conducted about a person, group, event, etc. All the aspects of the topic are covered in a case study. Action research is content in which an issue is investigated and resolved. In this article, we will look at the difference between a case study and an action research.

A case study is content in which you have to cover all the aspects of a topic. The topic can include a person, a group, an event, and many more things. There are many fields in which case studies are used and some of them are −

• Political science
• Anthropology
• Social work

A case study is written to learn about a topic as much as possible. It is difficult to publish it for a large number of viewers.

Types of Case Studies

Case studies are of different types which are discussed below −

Collective Case Studies

This is a type of case study in which a study is conducted on a group of people. This group can be a particular community, people engaged in a similar profession, people living in a society, etc.

Descriptive Case Studies

Descriptive case studies include the topic related to a descriptive theory. The information regarding the theory can be gathered and can be compared with the existing theory.

Explanatory Case Studies

These are the case studies in which researchers have to look for certain factors which have led to the cause of certain things.

Exploratory Case Studies

These are the case studies in which in-depth research related to a topic is conducted. Researchers can gather more information before creating a hypothesis on the topic.

Instrumental Case Studies

These are a type of case studies in which researchers are allowed by individuals or groups to understand them more. The research done on the individuals or group should be more than the things that observers can observe obviously.

Intrinsic Case Studies

These are a type of case studies in which a researcher performs research based on his personal interest. He can research on the behavior of his children, his hobbies, and many more.

Benefits of Case Studies

A case study has many benefits and you need to consider them before writing. Some of these benefits are listed below −

• Researchers can investigate those topics which cannot be replicated in a lab
• Researchers can answer the what why and how questions regarding a topic
• Researchers get the opportunity of researching why a strategy is better than others
• Hypotheses can be developed which can be tested through experimental research

Disadvantages of Case Studies

Case studies also have a few disadvantages which are listed below −

• Case studies cannot have a large number of viewers
• Cause and effect cannot be demonstrated
• It can be biased

Action Research

Action research is a type of research method in which an issue is investigated to find its solution. This type of research is usually done in social sciences and education field. The research is done to reduce the gap between theory and practical.

Types of Action Research

Acton research is of two types and we will discuss them here in detail.

• Participatory Action Research

Practical Action Research

Participatory action research.

This is a type of research in which a study is conducted on the participants who belong to a certain community. In this research, the participants share their experiences in their lives.

This is a type of research done on certain issues and solutions are provided to resolve them.

Benefits of Action Research

Action research has many benefits and they are listed below −

• Researchers can conduct the analysis according to the needs of an individual.
• Immediate and actionable path can be conducted through this research to resolve an issue

Disadvantages of Action research

Action research has a few disadvantages listed below −

• Replication of research studies is difficult as action research is very flexible.
• Making a structure of the action research in an ethical way is very difficult

Case studies and action research have a lot of differences and we will see them in the table below −

FAQs on Action Research vs. Case Study

1. differentiate between action research and case study..

Action research is conducted to identify a problem and provide a solution. Case studies are conducted to observe a particular phenomenon, event, individual, or group.

2. What is the aim of action research?

Acton research is conducted to identify a problem and provide a solution. It is also done to provide community-based knowledge which can impact processes like learning, teaching, etc.

3. How can action research be used in education?

Action research is conducted to reduce the gap between practical and theory. Educators find the solution to an issue after investigating it.

4. What is a case study?

A case study is an in-depth knowledge that is related to an individual, a group, or an event. Case studies are written to observe the complex issues but they do not provide any solution.

5. In which field are action research and case studies used?

Action research is mainly used in the educational field while case studies can be related to a lot of fields like medicine, psychology, etc.

• Related Articles
• Difference between Descriptive Research and Experimental Research
• Difference Between Correlational and Experimental Research
• Difference between Single Action and Double Action Guns
• Case Study: Meaning and Types
• Difference between Research Paper and Review Paper
• Difference between Use Case and Test Case
• Louis Vuitton Case Study
• Difference between Research Papers and Technical Articles for Journal Publication
• The Zombie Apocalypse case study - JavaScript
• Difference Between Theory of Action and Theory of Change
• Case Study of the Growth of Zara
• Case Study of The Growth Of H&M
• Quality Management in Software Development: A Case Study
• What is the difference between Func delegate and Action delegate in C#?
• What is the difference between include action and include directive in JSP?

Kickstart Your Career

Get certified by completing the course

Action Research vs Case Study : Know the Key Difference Between Two Qualitative Research Methods

A research method is nothing but a technique of inquiry which proceeds from the underlying philosophical assumptions to research design and data collection. Specific research methods imply various assumptions, skills, research practices and the choice of research approach influences the manner in which the data is collected. 

Among various research methods, the most popular and widely used design is qualitative research. This design consists of many philosophical perspectives and various research methods, of which includes  action research and case study research.

Action Research

Action research is a type of qualitative research, which is adopted by the researcher in order to solve the immediate problem arisen during the particular course of time. It is a way which bridges the gap between educational theory and professional practice by improvising their current practices. This type of research helps the researcher to improvise its current practices and is applied for researching into issues.

The main purpose of action research is to learn through action leading to personal or professional development. It enables researchers not only to suggest appropriate lines of action but also to investigate the actual effects of such actions. Further, this type of research is situation based, is useful in problem-solving and deals with individuals or groups with a common purpose of improving practice.

Action research is conducted in classrooms and organisations, where the practitioner will observe what happens and then identify an issue or problem that they need to address. Further according to the issues, ways to solve the problems are identified and applied by the practitioner in their practices. This approach is applied using qualitative designs to explain what is happening and to understand the effects of some educational intervention. 

Further, this research helps in addressing practical problems and in generating knowledge to produce change.

Methods used in collecting data in action research are:

• Observing individuals or groups
• Using audio and videotape recording
• Using structured or semi-structured interviews
• Taking field notes
• Conducting surveys or questionnaires

Case study research is more of a qualitative method of research where there is an in-depth study of an individual or a group of individuals. It explores a contemporary prodigy within its real-life context and provides an organised way of observing the events, collecting data, analysing information, and reporting the results.

Further, the case study method focuses on the description or exploration of a particular phenomenon, rather than identifying the cause and effect. This method includes both quantitative and qualitative data and allow the researchers to see beyond statistical results and understand human conditions like illiteracy, poverty, etc. 

Case studies is categorised in 3 ways: exploratory, explanatory and descriptive.

Exploratory case studies explore any event in the data which serves as a point of interest to the researcher. For example, a researcher conducting an exploratory case study on an individual’s learning process may ask questions, such as, “Does a student use any strategies when he learns a text?” This type of question results in further examination of the phenomenon. 

On the other hand, the explanatory case study examines the data carefully and explains the phenomenon occurred in the data.

Descriptive case studies describe the natural phenomena which occur within the data. For example, what are the strategies used by the learner?, etc. 

Case studies are useful as they help the researcher to analyse the data at a small level but there is a  tendency for the researcher to be biased at the time of interpreting the data. 

Methods used in collecting the data in the case study method are:

• Interviews, transcript analyses or protocol 
• An exploration of artifacts.
• A review of documents and archived record
• Direct participant observations
• Field studies

Difference between action research and case study

At times people confuse the action research method with that of case study as both are a little bit similar to each other. But in real-time, they are quite different.

• Action research focuses on solving the immediate problem whereas, case studies focus on a particular phenomenon for a longer period of time.
• Action research method emphasis on solving the problem whereas case study method emphasis on observing, analysing and interpreting a particular phenomenon or scenario.
• Researcher at times can also be the part of the action research whereas in case study researcher don’t take part in the research.

Now that you know the difference between the two approaches, choose the method accordingly and accomplish your research.

Five Vidya is a team of academic experts who joined hands to assist young scholars and researchers to successfully complete their PhD thesis. Our office and services are based out of Bangalore and Hyderabad (India). We provide academic services including PhD thesis writing, thesis editing, software implementation, journal manuscript writing, business case studies development, and so on

Our Services

• Topic and Research Proposal
• Problem Statement
• Base Papers
• Chapters Writing
• Questionnaire and Experiments
• Research Design

Implementation

• Matlab Projects
• Simulink Projects
• Python Projects
• Java Projects
• Ansys Projects

Journal Papers

• IEEE Papers
• Thought Clearing
• Development Editing
• Review Article
• Empirical Article
• Technical Article
• Qualitative Data Analysis
• Quantitative Data Analysis
• Request a Quote
• PhD Planner

Quick Links

• Privacy Policy
• Terms & Conditions
• Money Refund Policy
• Grievance Redressal

Disclaimer:" FiveVidya is a team of academic research consultants, writers and editors who provide ethical and comprehensive support for doctoral candidates for their research. FiveVidya does not provide any ready to submit work for their clients"

• Dr Nicole Brown

Social Research & Practice and Education Ltd.

• Publications
• List of all blog posts
• Practice As Research

Action research or case study?

When planning for a practice-based enquiry or small-scale study you will most often be confronted with the choice between an action research or case study approach. Strictly speaking, there are many approaches to enquiries, but for practical reasons the action research or case study approaches are amongst the most popular for teacher-researchers.

Your decision for one or the other approach must be well justified and to this end you must consult research methodology literature. However, in the following there will be a simplified exploration of the two approaches to get you started.

What is action research? Action research should be considered as a way of life in the classroom. As a reflective practitioner you will observe what happens in your class and then identify an issue or problem that you need to address. After consulting relevant literature you will then formulate a new approach or intervention, which you carry out in your classroom. Once you have worked with this intervention you will reflect and reconsider its effectiveness and impact and the cycle can start again. For a practice-based enquiry you may go through several cycles or through one cycle only. The advantage of the action research is that it naturally develops from your teaching practice and that it addresses real issues within your classroom. Typical critique of action researches would be that they are not rigorous or systematic enough.

What is case study? A case study is more difficult to understand because it can be a method as well as a methodology. Here we only look at case studies for their methodological function. If you want to learn more about a specific issue or you want to explore a particular problem or occurrence, then the case study is for you. The description of what makes a “case” differs in various research methodology publications, but generally speaking a “case” can refer to a group of people, a specific person or issue, a collective of ideas. The advantage of a case study is that you get to know the status quo in all its facets and so you gain a deep insight into your field of study. Common critique of the case study approach is that it is so specialised and specific to the context of the research that generalisability is lost. Sometimes it is also said that the mere description of a status quo is not practical for teachers because there are no changes. My argument would be that detailed knowlegde of what happens in your classroom or school can lead to recommendations for future practice. It is just that you do not enter a cyclical approach of evaluating and revisiting your suggested changes.

Action research or case study? Both approaches have their benefits and limitations within the realm of practice-based enquiries. The choice therefore depends on what it is that you want to find out. Are you planning to introduce a new teaching strategy or changes or interventions with some or all of your pupils? Or are you trying to explore a specific topic? The former would be a justification for action research, whereas the latter hints at a case study. You must be guided by your research focus, your research question or hypothesis and by the research methodology publications you consult.

Related posts:

• Getting started with educational research Getting started with educational research is a short introduction to...
• Writing an action plan How to write an action plan in order to improve...
• Book review: Doing research in education – Theory and practice This review is about the book "Doing research in education"....
• The relationship between creative and participatory approaches to research This is a presentation based on my article Scope and...

Leave a message:

Leave a reply cancel reply.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

 Yes, add me to your mailing list.